Welcome to your ultimate assistive technology resource!
 

Welcome to our Assistive Technology Archive. Have fun browsing!

 

Article #257: Separate Text-Only Version? No Thanks!

(Browse for more articles)

 
In an attempt to make their sites Large time and money investment
accessible to all, more and more websites Creating a separate accessible version can
are now offering text-only versions of obviously represents an extremely large
their sites. With the huge number of time and money investment. This can be
inaccessible websites out there, any offset if the site is database-driven,
attempt to make a website accessible to although there's still a time investment
one and all is highly commendable. involved in setting up this alternative
But is text-only the way forward? The W3C version - time that could have instead
have this to say about alternative been spent making the primary site
accessible sites: accessible to all.
And if all else fails... If, after best Less information
efforts, you cannot create an accessible Some text-only versions offer far less
page, provide a link to an alternative information and/or functionality than the
page. primary version of the site. Manchester
Hmmm... so according to the W3C a separate United's accessible version is a prime
accessible site is OK, but they do use example of this: the primary website
some pretty strong language to suggest features over 100 choices in the
that this should be avoided wherever navigation menu; the accessible version
possible. They're probably right too, just eight. For a busy webmaster, having
given the disadvantages of going down the to make updates to two versions of the
text-only route: same website can be a huge pain.
Text-only version may not be accessible If the website is 100% database driven
The most ironic thing about text-only then the separate text-only version will
versions, is that often they don't even automatically be updated with the primary
offer full accessibility. This could be version of the site. Although
for a number of reasons, two of the most database-driven sites are commonplace on
common being: the web, it is very rare that every single
- Non-descriptive link text: Visually page is drawn from the database. As such,
impaired Internet users can browse web even with a database-driven site separate
pages by tabbing from one link to the versions can often be left behind.
next. Link text such as 'click here' and Marginalisation of society
'more', which may feature in a text-only The final point, and perhaps the most
version, won't make any sense to them when important. One of the most famous quotes
doing this. about accessibility was made by Tim
- Inaccessible forms: For optimal Berners-Lee, the man who invented the
accessibility, prompt text should be Internet:
assigned to its form item, using the label The power of the Web is in its
for attribute. To check for this, a universality. Access by everyone
flashing cursor should appear in each form regardless of disability is an essential
box when the text next to it is clicked. aspect.
Primary website may be inaccessible to Creating a separate version for web users
site visitors with special needs can be seen as just one
One of the myths of web accessibility is more way of them being marginalised from
that accessibility is only about blind and every day society. Having a separate
disabled users. Accessibility is actually accessible version has been famously
about everyone being able to access your likened to a restaurant providing a side
website, both disabled and non-disabled, door down a back alley for disabled
regardless of the browsing technology customers, because the main entrance has a
they're using. couple of stairs leading in to the
For example, users accessing your website restaurant.
through WebTV, mobile phones, and PDAs, The idea of the Internet is that it's an
which have limited support for large inclusive medium, which everyone should be
images, Flash and JavaScript, may not be able to use and access. Visually impaired
able to access your site. Don't individuals particularly can now access a
underestimate the importance of this: in virtually unlimited source of information
2008 alone an estimated 58 million PDAs in a way that would never have been
will be sold (source: and one third of possible.
the world's population will own a wireless Text-only? No thanks!
device (source: There are therefore so many reasons as to
Lost branding opportunity why a separate text-only version isn't a
Some users may only need to make small good idea. Additionally, there are a such
adjustments to your site in order to be huge number of benefits to having an
able to effectively use it. For example, a accessible website that there's no excuse
site visitor who needs to slightly resize for not trying to make your main website
the text on your site may have to use the accessible to everyone.
text-only version if you don't allow this Certainly many big organisations are now
is the main version. This person then working towards offering accessible
won't be exposed to your online image and websites, which is highly commendable. So
branding, which you've undoubtedly spent come on guys, let's keep working to make
so long developing. sure the Internet is fully inclusive.






1 - A - B - C - D - 2 - 3 - 4 - 5 - 6 - 7 - 8 - 9 - 10 - 11 - 12 - 13 - 14 - 15 - 16 - 17 - 18 - 19 - 20 - 21 - 22 - 23 - 24 - 25 - 26 - 27 - 28 - 29 - 30 - 31 - 32 - 33 - 34 - 35 - 36 - 37 - 38 - 39 - 40 - 41 - 42 - 43 - 44 - 45 - 46 - 47 - 48 - 49 - 50 - 51 - 52 - 53 - 54 - 55 -